Microsoft App-V as an application virtualization solution: Pros & cons


My coworker Mark Van Noy has a lots of experience in the world of application virtualization as is confirmed in this current post on our website where he supplied a summary of various application streaming modern technologies and also the significant gamers in the application virtualization video game. Recognizing this, and also having Mark reveal us what gets on the rack regarding application virtualization services are worried, I asked Mark to “give us a taste” of among these services, and also Mark picked the one he’s had one of the most hands-on experience with: Microsoft Application Virtualization (App-V). Yet prior to I transform the mic over to Mark, that claims his walkthrough isn’t truly a complete tutorial however is meant mostly to make points a little much easier for individuals that could intend to experiment with the modern technologies, allow me present him once more by stating that Mark is a technological lead/architect at the College of Colorado Stone in the Greater Denver Location. As an infotech generalist, Mark grows on architecting brand-new devices and also solutions in manner ins which enable his consumers to recognize gains in performance, efficiency, and also price financial savings while making sure that IT stays a department that gives an affordable benefit. For additional information concerning him, you can discover him on LinkedIn. The flooring currently comes from Mark.

Taking a close take a look at App-V

Microsoft’s App-V, previously Softricity’s Softgrid prior to Microsoft’s procurement in 2006, is among the better-known application virtualization services that containerize applications. Our company absolutely felt it was a fairly fully grown remedy when we initially took on Softgrid as our application streaming remedy in2005 With greater than 14 years to advance, what can App-V do and also should business be making use of the modern technology today?

Pros of making use of App-V

Among the extra engaging functions of App-V is that it containerizes applications, consequently separating them from both various other applications and also the os itself. This can be very valuable for application versioning. The Python scripting language is an example of an application that frequently has numerous variations with details variations called for by details added applications. Instead of attempting to mount numerous variations of Python and also maintain the different variations from clashing– in addition to handling their courses so the reliant applications do not experience disputes– App-V can containerize applications with the variation of Python they require. Therefore, applications needing various variations of Python can run side-by-side on the very same computer system with no disputes given that they all have the natural environment they called for concluded with them inside their container.

App-V is additionally special in exactly how it streams applications to endpoint computer systems. When an application is packaged– sequencing in App-V parlance– an evaluation of the application’s start-up demands is instantly executed as component of the procedure. App-V after that utilizes that info to enable just the sections of the software program that are needed for the application to release to be streamed to customers for the first launch. After that the staying sections of the software program stream to the customer behind-the-scenes. This permits a much faster first launch in many cases than application streaming modern technologies that call for a complete download of the application prior to the application can start packing.

With the launch of Windows 10, the App-V customer is constructed right into the os for Windows 10 Business and also Education And Learning, so it no more calls for the acquisition of the Microsoft Desktop Computer Optimization Load to utilize. Nonetheless, the App-V customer requires to be made it possible for in spite of being integrated. Just establishing the Microsoft App-V Customer service to begin instantly will not appropriately allow the App-V integrated customer. The customer has to be made it possible for by either running the PowerShell cmdlet Enable-AppV from a PowerShell punctual after that restarting or establishing a GPO for Computer System Setup > Plans > Management Layouts > System > App-V > Enable App-V Customer and also established it to Allowed.

The App-V sequencer belongs to the easily downloaded and install Windows 10 Windows Analysis and also Implementation Set (ADK). This high schedule makes it very easy for any person to experiment with sequencing applications on Windows10 Setting up the sequencer right into a Hyper-V setting makes it extremely simple to utilize pictures to produce an extremely constant sequencing setting. Because a sensible variety of application compatibility concerns emerge throughout the sequencing procedure, making use of the ADK to check application compatibility can be a simple method to review the modern technology. Keep in mind, nevertheless, that there has actually been a concern with the sequencer given that the 1703 variation of the ADK that avoids the sequencer screen solution from beginning if Secure Boot is made it possible for, also in digital equipments. This possible issue has actually been verified to exist in the 1903 variation of the ADK.


Application compatibility benefits applications that are not bigger than 2GB to mount. For the 10 years that our company leveraged App-V, we took care of to efficiently series simply over 70 special applications. That number consisted of some applications that called for calling a permit web server on launch. We were additionally effective in layering some applications with reliant middleware right into different App-V containers to make sure that the middleware might be upgraded without needing to upgrade the application that depended on it. There sufficed applications that were sequenced that imaging time was measurably minimized by eliminating applications from master pictures and also network application was likewise minimized.


Sequencer step 1

Via making use of PowerShell cmdlets, applications can be completely pre-cached to systems. This is a really valuable attribute in scenarios in which an application is recognized to be utilized on a regular basis. By pre-caching an application, it executes like a neighborhood mount while the pre-cache procedure can take place throughout off-hours to avoid end-user interruptions.

Disadvantages of making use of App-V

The App-V streaming web server still calls for MDOP to acquire. Furthermore, the web server part has actually not been upgraded given that 2015 and also the sequencer has actually not been upgraded given that Windows 10 variation 1607 in2016 It shows up that App-V has actually not had any type of updates in greater than 3 years to any one of its elements. Such little focus to the item provides the perception that Microsoft is not extremely devoted to the modern technology.

Sequencer step 2

Sequencer step 3

The App-V streaming web server can just arrangement applications based upon individual teams. For circumstances where applications ought to comply with an individual around from Windows computer system to Windows computer system, this performance is all that is required. For scenarios where an application ought to be linked to a details computer system– for academic computer system laboratories with numerous individuals, as an example– the streaming web server is an inadequate fit at finest. SCCM does have indigenous assistance for App-V and also it sustains releasing applications by computer system collection in addition to the streaming performance. If an IT company is currently making use of SCCM, after that this might not be a disadvantage.



Regrettably, application compatibility has actually gone stale. Application compatibility has actually never ever been wonderful with App-V. The compatibility was boosting with each launch, however the launches have actually slowed down substantially. App-V still does not sustain sequencing chauffeurs and also just conditionally series solutions. Likewise, huge applications that go beyond 2GB in dimension can be anticipated to stop working to series. Some huge and also challenging applications such as ArcGIS, AutoCAD, and also Solidworks can not be sequenced to the most effective of my understanding. At the very least, we never ever efficiently sequenced them.



App-V containers do a terrific work of protecting against disputes while making various other monitoring devices function a lot more difficult to take care of those applications. The Computer registry is virtualized so making Computer registry modifies to do points like modification a permit web server can be hard to difficult. The data system is additionally virtualized protecting against duplicating data in or out of the container. All containerized modern technologies deal with these sorts of problems somewhat. Nonetheless, some suppliers have richer devices for tweaking exactly how containerized an application stays. Interaction in between containers can be extremely valuable for points such as common middleware or plugins to make sure that numerous items of software program do not need to be consistently covered in application containers. Relocating from a monolithic gold picture to quasi-monolithic containerized applications is an enhancement while staying much where application virtualization assures to at some point be.

MSIX and also the future of App-V

Microsoft has actually mentioned in different files and also blog sites that App-V is a core modern technology in the MSIX software program distribution system that is slated to change the heritage MSI system. It is presently a little bit obscure exactly how App-V suits the MSIX system. Nonetheless, after restricted screening with Microsoft’s sneak peek setting, it appears like the MSIX packager might be making use of some component of the App-V sequencer. My examination of 7-Zip showed that the MSIX packager had the very same issue recording the mount of the software program as I had actually formerly seen with App-V: the Documents Traveler tries to find 7-Zip when a data was right-clicked did not obtain caught damaging the performance. If MSIX is improving the App-V modern technology after that it will likely share the application compatibility difficulties of repackaging that App-V deals with.


Create Package step 3



If Microsoft totally rolls App-V right into MSIX after that the modern technology has a various obstacle: release. Presently, MSIX applications call for Microsoft Shop performance. Also if an application is authorized and also in your area duplicated to the target computer system, a message will certainly appear to the end-user educating them that sideloading have to be made it possible for to mount the application. Sideloading is noted as a programmer alternative and also when it is switched on it appears an alerting concerning exactly how side packing possibly permits dangerous software program to be mounted. Handling sideloading is very easy sufficient to do with Team Plan for taken care of computer systems. For BYOD systems sideloading will likely show even more bothersome as we have actually been instructing individuals to pick not to proceed when they see an alerting concerning possibly dangerous software program. I additionally think that MSIX will certainly call for a complete duplicate of the software program to be existing prior to it can mount and also release, however absolutely nothing is maintaining Microsoft from adjusting their modern technology to do greater than they have actually revealed.

With the uninterested function the Microsoft Shop has actually gotten to day, MSIX’s future does not look encouraging. Third-party suppliers are not likely to natively package their applications to consumers in such a way that will certainly call for consumers to activate programmer setting side loading. As the system presently stands it is an inadequate client experience. As a result, it appears practical to anticipate suppliers to proceed dispersing their software program in the setup.exe style. Therefore, if Microsoft rolls all App-V performance and also assistance right into MSIX and also the MSIX technique of software program circulation stops working to obtain grip, after that MSIX might drag App-V right into obscurity with it.

Included picture: Shutterstock/ TechGenix picture image

Message Sights:

Review Following